Cherreads

Man or a Monster? [Harry Potter AU]

luciferblackiv
7
chs / week
The average realized release rate over the past 30 days is 7 chs / week.
--
NOT RATINGS
984
Views
Synopsis
In the shadowed halls of Hogwarts, where magic hums and tensions simmer, a new figure steps into the fray: Alexander Potter, the enigmatic twin of James Potter, returning from the wandless wonders of Uagadou to join his brother in their fifth year. With his piercing hazel eyes, silver alchemical ring, and a mind sharper than any spell, Alexander is no ordinary wizard. As whispers of a rising Dark Lord and disappearing Muggleborns cast a pall over 1975, Alexander’s calculated elegance and detached morality unsettle allies and adversaries alike. Will his brilliance unite or divide the bonds of family and friendship in a school teetering on the edge of war? • ° Marauders era
VIEW MORE

Chapter 1 - Chapter 1: Winds of change

The air was heavy with the scent of rain-soaked earth as Alexander Potter stepped off the international Portkey platform in London, his polished leather boots sinking slightly into the damp cobblestones. The sky above was a bruised gray, the kind that promised a storm but held back, as if savoring the tension. He adjusted the collar of his long, tailored coat—charcoal, with a subtle sheen of silk—and scanned the bustling crowd with his piercing hazel eyes. His dark brown hair, meticulously parted, caught the faint light filtering through the clouds, a quiet flame against the muted world around him.

Five years had passed since he'd last spent more than a fleeting holiday in England. Uagadou had been his crucible, its wandless magic a discipline that resonated with his belief that true power stemmed from the self, not a crutch of wood and core. But now, at sixteen, he had mastered all the school could offer, and the pull of family—and perhaps something deeper—had drawn him back to Hogwarts. His decision to transfer was not impulsive; Alexander never acted without purpose. The OWLs awaited, a necessary step to cement his academic standing, but more than that, he wanted to walk the same halls as his twin, James, to bridge the chasm that had grown between them.

The Portkey terminal was a chaotic swirl of travelers, but Alexander moved through it with the grace of a predator, his presence parting the crowd like water. His silver alchemical ring, inscribed with a delicate "A" crowned by stag antlers, glinted faintly on his right hand. It was no mere ornament; it was his focus, his anchor for wandless magic, crafted in the sun-scorched forges of Uagadou. He carried no wand, and the absence felt like a declaration.

A familiar figure emerged from the throng—Charles Potter, his father, tall and broad-shouldered, with the same hazel eyes Alexander had inherited, though Charles's were warmer, less guarded. Beside him stood Euphemia, her dark hair streaked with silver, her face alight with a joy that softened the lines of age. Alexander's lips curved into a subtle smile, the kind that promised warmth but held something back.

"Alexander," Euphemia said, her voice trembling as she closed the distance and pulled him into an embrace. Her arms were fierce, as if she could anchor him to this moment, to this place. "You're home."

"Mother," he murmured, his voice smooth and melodic, like a low note on a piano. He returned the embrace with measured affection, his hands resting lightly on her shoulders. "It's good to be back."

Charles stepped forward, his gaze searching Alexander's face. "You've grown," he said, a faint note of pride undercut by something else—wariness, perhaps. "Taller, sharper. Uagadou's done you well."

"It has," Alexander replied, his tone neutral but laced with quiet confidence. "But I've missed you both."

The words were true, though Alexander's love was a complex thing, possessive and restrained, like a flame kept behind glass. He studied his parents, noting the faint lines of worry around Euphemia's eyes, the way Charles's posture stiffened slightly, as if bracing for something unspoken. They knew of his decision to transfer, but the details remained a shadow between them.

"Where's James?" Alexander asked, his eyes flicking to the crowd.

"Waiting at home," Charles said, his voice careful. "He's… eager to see you. It's been a while."

Alexander's smile tightened, a flicker of something unreadable crossing his face. "Eager. Of course."

The journey to the Potter estate in Godric's Hollow was quiet, the family's sleek, enchanted car gliding through the misty countryside. Alexander sat in the back, his posture impeccable, his gaze fixed on the rolling hills beyond the window. Euphemia chatted softly about the village, the neighbors, the small comforts of home, but Alexander's responses were measured, his attention split between her words and the weight of what lay ahead.

The estate loomed into view, a sprawling manor of ivy-clad stone, its windows glowing like beacons against the gathering dusk. As the car rolled to a stop, the front door swung open, and James Potter bounded out, his dark hair a mess, his grin wide but tinged with something sharp—relief, perhaps, or defiance.

"Alex!" James called, his voice carrying the rough warmth of someone who wore his heart on his sleeve. He stopped short, taking in his twin's appearance—the tailored coat, the immaculate hair, the calm intensity of his gaze. "Merlin's beard, you look like you've stepped out of a portrait."

Alexander's lips quirked, a hint of amusement softening his features. "And you look like you've been wrestling a hippogriff, as usual."James laughed, but it was a brittle sound, and his eyes held a storm of emotions—love, resentment, curiosity. He closed the distance and pulled Alexander into a rough hug, one that Alexander returned with a careful, almost clinical precision.

"Five years, you prat," James muttered, pulling back to study him. "You couldn't write more than twice a term?"

"I was busy," Alexander said, his tone light but unapologetic. "Mastering wandless magic isn't a hobby, James."

James's jaw tightened, but he didn't press. Instead, he slung an arm around Alexander's shoulders, guiding him inside.

"Come on, Mum's got dinner ready. You're probably used to eating lion or something out there."

"Only on Tuesdays," Alexander deadpanned, earning a snort from his twin.

The dining room was a study in warmth and elegance, its long oak table set with fine china and flickering candles. A fire crackled in the hearth, casting shadows across the walls, where portraits of past Potters watched with silent approval. Euphemia had outdone herself—roast lamb, glazed carrots, a bottle of elf-made wine for the adults. Alexander took his seat with the grace of a diplomat, his movements deliberate, his expression serene.

Dinner began with the clink of cutlery and the soft hum of conversation. Charles asked about Uagadou, and Alexander answered with eloquence, describing the school's lunar-lit halls, the gesture-based magic, the way the air thrummed with ancient power. His words were precise, painting vivid images, but there was a distance to them, as if he were recounting someone else's life.

"You must've been top of your class," Euphemia said, her eyes shining with pride.

"I was," Alexander said simply, his tone neither boastful nor modest. "But mastery isn't a destination. It's a process."

James, who had been quiet, speared a carrot with unnecessary force. "So, what's this about transferring to Hogwarts?" he asked, his voice casual but edged with something raw. "You've never wanted to be here before."

The room stilled, the weight of the question settling like dust. Alexander met his twin's gaze, his hazel eyes steady, unyielding. "I've learned what Uagadou could teach me," he said. "Hogwarts offers the OWLs, a broader curriculum, and… a chance to be closer to you."James blinked, caught off guard by the last part. "Closer to me?" he echoed, a mix of skepticism and hope in his voice."You're my brother," Alexander said, his voice soft but deliberate, each word chosen with care. "Distance doesn't change that, but proximity might… clarify things."

Euphemia reached for Charles's hand, her smile trembling. "It's wonderful, Alexander. To have you both under one roof again."Charles nodded, though his eyes lingered on Alexander, searching for something beneath the surface. "It'll be a change," he said. "Hogwarts isn't Uagadou. You'll need supplies—books, robes. James already has his wand, of course."

"I won't need a wand," Alexander said, his tone calm but firm. He raised his right hand slightly, the silver ring catching the candlelight. "This is enough."

James's eyes narrowed, a flicker of old resentment surfacing. "Still think wands are a crutch, eh?""I think dependency is a crutch," Alexander corrected, his voice smooth as silk. "A wand is a tool, James. A fine one, for you. But I prefer my own path."

The words hung in the air, a quiet challenge. James's grip tightened on his fork, but he forced a grin. "Fair enough. Just don't expect me to start waving my hands around like a lunatic."

"Perish the thought," Alexander said, a faint smile curving his lips.

The conversation shifted, easing into lighter topics—Hogwarts houses, Quidditch, the upcoming term. But beneath the surface, emotions churned. James's laughter was too loud, his glances at Alexander too frequent. Euphemia's warmth was tinged with worry, Charles's pride with caution. And Alexander, ever composed, watched it all with the quiet intensity of a chess master studying the board.

•••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••

The next morning, the Potters set out for Diagon Alley, the cobblestone streets alive with the bustle of witches and wizards preparing for the school year. The air was crisp, the sky a pale blue streaked with wisps of cloud. Alexander walked beside James, his long coat billowing slightly, his posture impeccable. James, in contrast, was all kinetic energy, his wand tucked into his pocket, his grin infectious as he pointed out familiar shops.

"Flourish and Blotts first," Charles said, leading the way. "Books for both of you, then robes for Alexander."

The bookstore was a labyrinth of shelves, the air thick with the scent of parchment and ink. Alexander moved through the aisles with purpose, his fingers trailing lightly over the spines as he selected his texts—Advanced Transfiguration, The Standard Book of Spells (Grade 5), Ancient Runes and Their Applications. His choices were precise, each book a piece of the puzzle he intended to master.

James, meanwhile, grabbed his own books with less care, tossing them into a basket. "You're gonna bury yourself in these, aren't you?" he said, eyeing Alexander's stack.

"Knowledge is a weapon," Alexander replied, his tone light but his eyes serious. "I prefer to be well-armed."

James snorted, but there was a flicker of admiration in his gaze. "You're such a Ravenclaw."

"Perhaps," Alexander said, his smile enigmatic. "We'll see what the Hat thinks."

At Madam Malkin's, Alexander stood still as a seamstress pinned his new robes, her wand darting to adjust the fabric. The black material was of the finest quality, tailored to his lean frame with an elegance that set him apart from the other students. James lounged nearby, watching with a mix of amusement and unease.

"You look like you're about to teach the class, not sit in it," James said.

"Good," Alexander replied, his voice low. "Perception is half the battle."

The final stop was Eeylops Owl Emporium, where Alexander selected a sleek, black owl with eyes like polished onyx. "For correspondence," he said, stroking the bird's feathers with a gentleness that belied his usual reserve. James, who already had his owl, watched in silence, his expression unreadable.

As they left the alley, bags in hand, Alexander paused, his gaze lingering on the crowd—their faces, their movements, their secrets. He was home, but this was no simple return. Hogwarts awaited, a new stage for his ambitions, his strategies, his carefully guarded heart. And James, his mirror and his opposite, would be there too, a reminder of the ties that bound them, and the tensions that might yet tear them apart.

The storm was coming, and Alexander Potter was ready to meet it.