The light flicked on, and I blinked and froze! What the... Mickie had dyed her hair black without telling me? Why would she do that? She knew how much a loved her pretty red hair! But then she turned her head to the side to look at me...
"Molls?" I gasped in shock, unable to believe it! My baby sister Molly had taken Mickie's place! What the fuck! I rolled aside, and she made the cutest little whimper of disappointment as my cock left her empty. I grabbed one of Mickie's pillows and yanked it down between us, though I don't know why I was bothering. Was I really worried she might see my dick, when I'd just finished cumming in her? Talk about locking the stable door after the horse has been stolen!
"Uhhh... hi, Jax," she bashfully, guiltily smiled, slowly wiping the tears from her cheeks.
"Fuck me, that was hot! Even better than I thought it would be!" Mickie's soft, sultry voice, and I turned my head. She was standing naked at the door to her bathroom, one hand on the light switch she'd just hit, the other slowly fingering herself as I watched.
"What the fuck, Mickie!" I demanded.
"You remember what you said, when I first told you I was bi?" she smiled, slowly, seductively stalking towards us. "You said being with a girl still counted as cheating if I did it without you... but if I ever decided I wanted to have a threesome I could pick any girl I wanted, just as long as she was hot! Well, they don't come any hotter than this sexy little sister of yours, that's for sure!" She rolled herself into the bed on Molly's other side, running her fingers into her hair, the two of them meeting in a soft, giggling kiss on the lips as I watched. I'd never noticed before, but other than the colour of their hair and a few subtle differences in their facial features, they really did look almost identical—no wonder I hadn't been able to tell!
"I never meant my own sister!" I objected, vigorously shaking my head. "I mean... she was a virgin, for Christ's sake! Unless..."
"I am. Or, I mean... I was," she admitted, turning back to face me, nervously biting her lip. Fuck! I couldn't believe I'd just taken my own baby sister's virginity! I never would have been so rough if I'd known! I mean... I never would have fucked her at all, of course! But I especially wouldn't have been so rough! "Why else do you think we needed to trick you? We knew you'd never agree... we didn't have any other choice! But now that you've done it already, you don't have to freak out about it anymore! You can just enjoy having me any time you like!"
"Any time..." I repeated dumbly, completely lost by what she seemed to be saying.
"I want to date you both, Jackson," Mickie chimed in, speaking slowly and distinctly, like she was talking to somebody with a brain injury or something. Which, come to think of it, might not have been too far from the truth at the moment. "I've been doing the whole cock-only thing ever since we started dating... and it's been wonderful, don't get me wrong! I love you! But... I just miss pussy, dammit! I want to start dating Molly now, too! I want your permission... and in exchange, if you agree... you get to fuck either of us, or both of us together, any time you want!"
"Seriously?" I gasped... but I couldn't deny, my cock was twitching a little, just thinking about it. "This can't really be what you want, is it Molls? I mean... you were the one who set me up with Mickie in the first place!" The two of them had been best friends ever since they'd first met. I'd always had a little crush, but it hadn't been until Molly had given me her blessing that I'd finally made a move.
"Only because I couldn't have you for myself, and wanted you to have someone good for a change!" she giggled. She twisted up onto her side to face me, grabbing the pillow I'd placed between us and tossing it aside. "But... that isn't exactly true any more, not if you agree." She bit her lip, reaching up to run her fingers through my hair... she leaned in, kissing me straight on my mouth! I gasped into her lips in surprise! But she was just so lovingly, patiently persistent, I couldn't help but start kissing her back. I didn't even resist when she slipped her tongue into my mouth, wrapping her in my arms and holding her tight.
"I love you, Jax!" she breathed into my lips. "And I really, really like Mickie, too! I want to be with you both!"
"I love you, Molls!" I closed my eyes and moaned. It was true, dammit! She was my sister, of course I loved her... but I wasn't entirely oblivious! Maybe it had taken the sexual equivalent of being hit by a bus to point it out to me, but now that I'd recognized the similarities between them, I couldn't deny that it was true; part of the reason I loved Mickie so much was because she reminded me of my sister. Not just physically, either—I'd never let myself realize it, but all the things I loved best about Mickie, I'd learned to love by seeing them in Molly, first!
"Now that we finally have that settled..." Mickie laughed, leaning in from behind to kiss Molly's neck. "Lay on your back and slide up the bed a bit! It's been so long since I've gotten to taste one, and I am absolutely dying to eat your brothers cum out of your pretty little pink pussy!"
"Okay," Molly giggled shyly, and moved to do as she'd been asked. I moved up as well. I was recovering pretty quickly, but I wasn't there yet; I wanted more of Molly's kisses,
to get me the rest of the way!